A criminal charge is an accusation, not proof of guilt. The burden of proof identifies who must establish a disputed issue and the level of proof required. At a criminal trial, the prosecution must prove each element of the charged offense beyond a reasonable doubt.
Georgia’s presumption-of-innocence statute, O.C.G.A. § 16-1-5, protects every person accused of a crime. This protection is not limited to U.S. citizens. The defendant does not have to establish innocence before the prosecution must prove its case.
What does “beyond a reasonable doubt” mean? It is the demanding standard used to decide criminal guilt. It is not the same as deciding that guilt is more likely than not. It also does not require eliminating every imaginable or speculative doubt. Jurors must follow the court’s instructions and assess the evidence concerning each element of the charge.
For example, evidence that an incident occurred does not necessarily establish who committed it or whether the required intent existed. A defense may challenge identification, the reliability of testimony, the handling of evidence, or whether the facts satisfy the offense’s legal definition. Which issues matter depends on the charge and the evidence.
Criminal and civil cases use different standards. Preponderance of the evidence is commonly used in civil disputes, and clear and convincing evidence applies to particular issues. Neither replaces the prosecution’s obligation to prove criminal guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. A prosecutor does not ordinarily bring a private civil damages claim on behalf of a plaintiff.
The trial standard should also not be confused with the standards used for an arrest, a search, a preliminary proceeding, or particular defenses and motions. Different legal questions may carry different burdens. A lawyer must identify the rule that applies to the specific issue.
If you face a criminal accusation, preserve documents and notices and obtain advice about your court dates and available defenses. Castan, Lecca & Boeschen can discuss your situation and explain the process. The outcome depends on the facts and applicable law; no result is guaranteed.




